What Are Bourbon Store Picks?
If you’ve been in the bourbon world for more than five minutes, chances are you’ve heard about store picks. These are single barrel bourbons (or ryes) selected by a retailer, liquor store, or tasting group. On paper, that means you’re getting a unique bottle — something different from the standard shelf version.
The appeal is clear: exclusivity, collectibility, and the chance to find a hidden gem. But here’s the real question: are bourbon store picks worth it, or just overhyped marketing?
Store Picks vs. Regular Bourbon Bottles
A store pick single barrel can be incredible — or completely average. Since no two barrels are the same, the whiskey can range from bold and complex to flat and forgettable.
-
Retail Price: Usually the same or slightly higher than the standard release
-
Secondary Price: Often inflated if the store has hype or uses flashy stickers
-
Flavor Profile: Highly variable — that’s the fun and the risk
For example, while some Knob Creek or Four Roses store picks blow away shelf bottles, others may not justify the premium price.
Why Store Picks Are So Hyped
Three main factors fuel the store pick craze:
-
Scarcity Marketing – “Only our store has this barrel.” Limited supply creates urgency.
-
Custom Stickers & Collectibility – Creative or funny labels drive buzz, even if the whiskey is average.
-
Community Hype – Once bourbon groups label a store’s picks as legendary, demand skyrockets.
This mix of scarcity, design, and word-of-mouth creates a FOMO-driven chase that isn’t always backed up by what’s in the glass.
Are Store Picks Worth the Money?
The answer depends on where and how you buy them.
-
At retail price: Many store picks are fantastic values, especially when chosen by a store with a strong reputation.
-
At inflated secondary prices: You’re usually better off buying other single barrel bourbons that outperform them.
Great alternatives at fair prices include:
-
Russell’s Reserve Single Barrel
-
Four Roses Single Barrel
-
Wild Turkey Rare Breed
-
Elijah Craig Barrel Proof
How to Pick the Right Store Pick
Not all store picks are created equal. Here’s what to look for:
-
Who Selected It: Does the store have a reputation for good barrels?
-
Transparency: Are details like age, warehouse, and tasting notes shared?
-
Price vs. Shelf: Is it fairly priced compared to the regular release?
-
Try Before You Buy: Many stores offer sample pours — always taste if you can.
Final Thoughts on Bourbon Store Picks
So, are bourbon store picks worth it?
-
Yes, if you grab them at retail from a trusted store.
-
No, if you’re overpaying for a flashy sticker or chasing hype.
At the end of the day, bourbon is about sharing good pours with good people. A well-selected store pick can elevate your collection, but you don’t need a $300 stickered bottle to enjoy great whiskey.
0 comments